What Westminster gets wrong about the NHS - Parliament Matters podcast, Episode 98

News

What Westminster gets wrong about the NHS - Parliament Matters podcast, Episode 98

27 Jun 2025

We are joined this week by two guests who bring invaluable insight into the intersection of health policy and parliamentary life. Dr. Sarah Wollaston and Steve Brine – both former MPs, health policy experts, and co-hosts of the podcast Prevention is the New Cure – share their experiences of how the House of Commons handles health and social care.

Please help us by completing our Listener Survey. It will only take a few minutes.

LISTEN

Both Sarah Wollaston and Steve Brine chaired the Commons Health Select Committee during their time in Parliament, and both bring broader career experience: Sarah as a former GP and Steve as a former Health Minister. They offer a candid and often striking comparison between GP surgeries and MP surgeries, revealing how health and social care concerns often dominate the concerns constituents bring to their representatives. Their experiences underscore how central the NHS is to public life and how fraught it is in political terms.

We explore the dangers MPs face when navigating NHS policy, particularly around controversial local hospital closures and service changes. Steve recounts his own strategic focus on healthcare in Winchester and the delicate balance between constituency advocacy and ministerial responsibility. While Sarah shares her frustration with the legislative process, particularly during the Lansley reforms, when her medical expertise was side-lined by the party whips.

The conversation moves to Labour’s current proposals for NHS reform. Our guests reflect on the gap between political rhetoric and delivery, particularly the challenge of achieving meaningful change in a system under financial and structural pressure.

Turning to the role of Parliament, Sarah and Steve reflect on the importance – and limits – of select committees in influencing policy. Drawing on their own time as committee chairs, they describe the committee corridor as one of the few places in Parliament where serious scrutiny and cross-party collaboration take place. Yet they also lament MPs broader failure to engage seriously with evidence or exercise proper scrutiny of departmental spending.

Finally, as more than 100 Labour MPs signal a potential rebellion over proposed cuts to Personal Independence Payments, we explore the culture of dissent at Westminster. Steve and Sarah – both with a track record of principled rebellion – offer advice to the new intake of MPs weighing loyalty against conscience. Their message is clear: in the long run, the votes you regret are the ones where you didn’t make a stand.

← Back to Parliament Matters homepage

Listen on our YouTube channel (captioned)

Subscribe to our YouTube channel

Our guests

Dr Sarah Wollaston

Dr Sarah Wollaston was the Member of Parliament for Totnes from 2010 until 2019. Unusually for a UK parliamentary candidate, she was first selected in an open primary, chosen as the Conservative candidate by local voters including those who were not party members. She chaired the House of Commons Health and Social Care Committee from 2014 to 2019. From 2017 to 2019 she also chaired the Commons Liaison Committee, which coordinates the work of other committees and questions the Prime Minister of the day. In February 2019, amid ongoing fallout from the Brexit referendum, she resigned from the Conservative Party and went on to join The Independent Group (TIG). Later in 2019 she joined the Liberal Democrats, but lost her seat in the December general election. After leaving Parliament, she served as chair of NHS Devon - the county’s Integrated Care Board - but resigned in 2024 due to concerns about the level of funding provided to deliver service requirements.

Steve Brine

Steve Brine was elected as the Conservative MP for Winchester in 2010. In 2016 he joined the Government as a junior Whip. In 2017 he went on to be a Minister in the Department of Health, later the Department of Health and Social Care. He briefly lost the Conservative whip in September 2019 after voting in favour of Hilary Benn’s backbench bill that forbade Prime Minister Boris Johnson from withdrawing the UK from the EU before the end of January 2020. He returned to the health portfolio in 2022, as chair of the House of Commons Health and Social Care Committee, until standing down from Parliament when the general election was called in May 2024.

Resources

Steve Brine and Sarah Wollaston

Prevention is the New Cure podcast

Hansard Society

The Estimates: a procedural guide

House of Commons Library

Debate on the Main Estimate for the Department of Health and Social Care

Transcript

Please note, this transcript is automatically generated. There may consequently be minor errors and the text is not formatted according to our style guide. If you wish to reference or cite the transcript copy below, please first check against the audio version above.

Intro: [00:00:00] You are listening to Parliament Matters, a Hansard Society production supported by the Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust. Learn more at hansardsociety.org.uk/pm.

Ruth Fox: Welcome to Parliament Matters, the podcast about the institution at the heart of our democracy, Parliament itself. I'm Ruth Fox.

Mark D'Arcy: And I'm Mark D'Arcy, and welcome to a slightly different edition of this podcast. We are joined in the Parliament Matters studio today by two fellow podcasters and former MPs and health policy experts, Dr. Sarah Wollaston and Steve Brine.

Ruth Fox: Both used to chair the Commons Health Select Committee. In her previous career, Sarah was a doctor and Steve served as a health minister. Now they collaborate on a health and politics podcast, 'Prevention is the New Cure'.

Mark D'Arcy: And Sarah and Steve, I wanted to start by looking at how health issues, how NHS issues, feed into the lives of parliamentarians. Sarah, you went from being a GP to being an [00:01:00] MP and from a GP surgery to an MP surgery. Were you surprised at the kind of NHS issues that were brought to you as a parliamentarian?

Sarah Wollaston: I thought it was extraordinary how similar my surgeries were. I guess you could say that except for nobody took their clothes off.

Full transcript →

Use the links below to subscribe to the Hansard Society's Parliament Matters podcast on your preferred app, or search for 'Parliament Matters' on whichever podcasting service you use. If you are unable to find our podcast, please email us here.

Apple

YouTube Podcasts

Spotify

More ways to subscribe

Parliament Matters homepage

Latest / Highlights

News / Parliament Matters Bulletin: What’s coming up in Parliament this week? 15-19 September 2025

Peers will vote on the assisted dying bill’s Second Reading, while MPs will question the new Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood MP and Lord Chancellor David Lammy MP. The Commons will debate the Employment Rights, English Devolution and Community Empowerment, and Sentencing Bills, as Peers examine the Planning and Infrastructure and Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bills. Committees will hear evidence on arms exports to Israel and the Online Safety Act. MPs will also debate an e-petition on SEND support and consider a Ten Minute Rule Bill on child poverty strategy, including removing the two-child limit for Universal Credit. The youngest minister in nearly two centuries will make his first appearance before a Select Committee. ❓ We value your thoughts. Please click here to let us know what you think of the Parliament Matters Bulletin in our reader survey.

News / Assisted dying bill - special series #16: The Bill makes its debut in the House of Lords - Parliament Matters podcast, Episode 106

As Peers embark on a marathon two-day Second Reading debate on the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill – the measure that would legalise assisted dying in England and Wales – we are joined by former Clerk of the Parliaments, Sir David Beamish, to decode the drama. With more than two hundred members of the House of Lords lining up to speak, Sir David explains why, despite the intensity of the arguments, no one expects the Bill to be rejected at this stage. Instead, the real fight will come later, after Peers get into the clause-by-clause detail and see what defects can be remedied. Please help us by completing our Listener Survey. It will only take a few minutes.

Briefings / The assisted dying bill: A guide to the legislative process in the House of Lords

Having passed through the House of Commons, the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill - the Bill to legalise assisted dying in England and Wales - must now go through its legislative stages in the House of Lords. This guide explains the special procedures for legislation in the House of Lords, and for Private Members’ Bills in particular. It answers some frequently asked questions, including how Peers might block the Bill, and gives an explanation of each stage of the process, from Second to Third Reading.

Briefings / Delegated powers in the assisted dying bill: Issues for the attention of the House of Lords

Like many pieces of primary legislation, the assisted dying bill leaves much of the practical and policy detail to be worked out later by Ministers through regulations. After the Bill’s Second Reading in the House of Commons, we published a briefing which drew attention to two of its delegated powers. But since then the Bill has been heavily amended, prompting new questions: how have its delegated powers evolved, do these changes strengthen or weaken the approach to the delegation of ministerial power, and are further amendments needed and if so, why?

News / Is Parliament at the root of the country's problems? - Parliament Matters podcast, Episode 105

Does Parliament itself lie at the root of some of Britain’s political and economic difficulties? Lord Goodman argues that it does and so makes the case for urgent parliamentary reform. This week we also examine the implications of a Downing Street reshuffle that has created a “Chief Secretary to the Prime Minister,” raising new questions about accountability in the Commons. The discussion ranges from Angela Rayner’s uncertain position, Nigel Farage’s controversial US appearance, and the Greens’ leadership contest, to the growing use of artificial intelligence in parliamentary work. Please help us by completing our Listener Survey. It will only take a few minutes.