Following Kemi Badenoch’s election, this episode explores the challenges she faces as the new Leader of the Opposition. What does it take to build an effective Opposition? What strategic decisions, policy initiatives, and personnel choices must she navigate? What resources and procedural tools can she use to challenge the Government and build a compelling public profile? How does she balance party cohesion with presenting a credible alternative government and preparing for future elections?
Nigel Fletcher, political historian and founder of the Centre for Opposition Studies, joins us to discuss what defines an effective Leader of the Opposition. We explore the nuances of opposition strategy, including the complex process of shaping a shadow cabinet. Badenoch must perform a high-stakes balancing act—critiquing government policy while preparing her party as a viable alternative. We debate critical aspects of her role, from parliamentary strategy to engaging effectively with the media. Her “straight-talking” style may attract public attention, but it also brings risks if her statements cross into controversial territory.
The episode covers essential resources at the opposition's disposal, such as "Short money" public funding, and explores the logistical challenges of running an efficient office without the governmental support systems ministers enjoy. We also examine the dynamics within the Conservative Party. With several prominent figures opting out of Badenoch’s shadow cabinet, how will she manage rival ambitions and maintain unity? And we explore the historical tactics the opposition has used in Parliament to pressurise the government and capture public support.
Tune in for an in-depth discussion of the intricacies of setting up an effective opposition—and a candid look at the challenges ahead for Kemi Badenoch as she embarks on this role.
Dr Nigel Fletcher
Dr Nigel Fletcher is an academic and political historian who co-founded the Centre for Opposition Studies. Until recently he was a Teaching Fellow in Politics and Contemporary History at King's College London. Before academia, Dr Fletcher worked for the Conservative Research Department during their last period in Opposition and became a Special Adviser to the Shadow Cabinet. He has also served as a local councillor on Greenwich Council, including as its Leader of the Opposition.
Nigel Fletcher, The worst job in politics - Becoming Leader of the Opposition (Centre for Opposition Studies, 2024)
Nigel Fletcher, How to be in Opposition - Life in the Political Shadows (Biteback Publishing, 2011)
Nigel Fletcher, The Not Quite Prime Ministers - Leaders of the Opposition 1783-2020 (Biteback Publishing, 2023)
The challenges Kemi Badenoch faces as the new Leader of the Opposition.
Building an effective Opposition: navigating strategic decisions, setting policy priorities, and selecting key personnel to structure a cohesive shadow cabinet.
Resources and tools for the Leader of the Opposition: accessing "Short money" public funding and procedural tools to effectively challenge the government.
Running an efficient opposition office without the extensive infrastructure and support available to the government.
The balancing act: critiquing government policies while positioning the party as a credible alternative.
Developing a strong public profile through effective media engagement and building public support.
The potential risks and rewards of Badenoch's “straight-talking” style.
Managing internal party dynamics: handling competing ambitions as high-profile figures opt out of the shadow cabinet.
Historical tactics the Opposition has used in Parliament to apply pressure on the government.
Please note, this transcript is automatically generated. There are consequently minor errors and the text is not formatted according to our style guide. If you wish to reference or cite the transcript copy below, please first check against the audio version above.
Intro: [00:00:00] You are listening to Parliament Matters, a Hansard Society production, supported by the Joseph Rowntree Charitable Trust. Learn more at hansardsociety.org.uk/pm.
Ruth Fox: Welcome to Parliament Matters, the podcast about the institution at the heart of our democracy, Parliament itself. I'm Ruth Fox.
Mark D'Arcy: And I'm Mark D'Arcy.
Ruth Fox: And in this special edition, we're going to look at the business of setting up shop as Leader of the Opposition.
Mark D'Arcy: Well, it's a new political era, we have a new Prime Minister, and now we have a new Leader of the Opposition. Kemi Badenoch had her first stint at Prime Minister's Question Time, to, it has to be said, mixed reviews. But one Prime Minister's Question Time doesn't the term of a Leader of the Opposition make.
There's an awful lot that goes into being the Leader of His Majesty's Loyal [00:01:00] Opposition. So what kind of things go into that operation? How is strategy determined? How Personnel decisions, like who's in the shadow cabinet and who's not, made. Well, with us to talk about all those questions and much, much more is Nigel Fletcher, one of the founders of the Centre for Opposition Studies, a political historian who's written books like the Not Quite Prime Ministers, a study of opposition leaders who didn't make it into Downing Street, and another book called Institutionalised Dissent about the role of opposition, plus another one still called How to Be in Opposition. So, Nigel, this is obviously very, very much your subject and you can see whole new chapters of your various books unfolding as Kemi Badenoch starts taking the decisions that will shape how she takes on Keir Starmer's government.
Nigel Fletcher: Yes, indeed. I wonder whether I should perhaps set up a book stall in sort of the reception of Portcullis House for new shadow ministers. to find my pearls of wisdom if they're of any use to them. But yes, it's one of the great delights, having made my sort of life studying opposition, which gets very little attention, really, [00:02:00] in the study of politics, when this cycle comes around and suddenly people are very interested in it and want to examine what is the role of the Leader of the Opposition and the shadow cabinet, and particularly for a party that's been in government for a long time, when they go into opposition, the real shock that they have of finding themselves without the support they're used to in government, and trying to get used to a whole new skill set, it suddenly focuses people's attention a lot more on this topic.
Mark D'Arcy: What are your impressions, first of all, of Kemi Badenoch at the very start of her term? Do you see the kind of the ship of opposition being constructed in the shipyard, if you like?
Nigel Fletcher: Yes, I think she has got a bit of a challenge that others perhaps haven't had in the past, that she has no experience of being in opposition.
This does tend to happen for leaders who come in after a long period of their party being in government.
Mark D'Arcy: She's only been in Parliament since 2017.
Use the links below to subscribe to the Hansard Society's Parliament Matters podcast on your preferred app, or search for 'Parliament Matters' on whichever podcasting service you use. If you are unable to find our podcast, please email us here.
The UK Spending Review outlines how Government funds will be allocated over several years. Unlike the Budget, which raises revenue, the Review decides how it is spent. But how is it approved? What role does Parliament play if it doesn’t vote on the Review itself? This blog explores how the Spending Review works, how it differs from the Budget, and how Parliament holds the Government to account through the Estimates process.
On Friday 13 June, the House of Commons will once again debate the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, which would legalise assisted dying in England and Wales. Specifically, it will hold a second day of Report Stage, during which the whole House will debate and vote on amendments. This briefing explains the structure of Report Stage, what happened on the first day of Report Stage, how amendments are selected and grouped, on which amendments a decision can still be taken, and the likely sequence of events this Friday, including whether a final vote will take place.
The Chancellor, Rachel Reeves MP, will deliver a statement on the Spending Review. MPs will resume Report Stage of the assisted dying bill and debate key legislation on football governance, mental health, and planning and infrastructure. Peers and MPs are expected to resolve their standoff over AI and copyright in the Data (Use and Access) Bill. The Commons Defence Committee will hear from the lead reviewers of the Strategic Defence Review, while a Lords Committee will examine the Chagos Archipelago sovereignty issue. The Hansard Society’s Director will give evidence to the Modernisation Committee about access to the House of Commons and its procedures.
In this episode, we explore why ministers keep bypassing Parliament to make major announcements to the media — and whether returning to the Despatch Box might help clarify their message. We unpack the Lords' uphill battle to protect creators’ rights in the Data Use and Access Bill, challenge claims that the Assisted Dying Bill lacks scrutiny, and examine early findings from a Speaker’s Conference on improving security for MPs, as threats and intimidation against politicians continue to rise. Please help us by completing our Listener Survey. It will only take a few minutes.
Our evidence on treaty scrutiny has been published by the House of Lords International Agreements Committee. Our submission outlines the problems with the existing framework for treaty scrutiny and why legislative and cultural change are needed to improve Parliament's scrutiny role. Our evidence joins calls for a parliamentary consent vote for the most significant agreements, a stronger role for Parliament in shaping negotiating mandates and monitoring progress, and a sifting committee tasked with determining which agreements warrant the greatest scrutiny.
